Homebirth in the Washington Post

Just a quick link to a recent article in the Washington Post about why a journalist there chose to have a planned homebirth.  I think she does a good job of articulating the many benefits associated with homebirth for low-risk women, but she also emphasized that this choice is not right for everyone (obviously).  Nice to see homebirth getting some major press, though!  The article can be found HERE!

Posted in Homebirth, Labor and Birth, News | Leave a comment

The first growth spurt–truly no joke!!

I knew, going into all of this, that all babies hit their first growth spurt around 3 weeks or so, and that during this time they want to nurse constantly and are more fussy than usual.  I actually, logically KNEW about this before it happened; I had advised mothers about this, told women that this will happen and they need to look out for it etc. etc.  Generally I would say something like this: around 3 weeks your baby will go through a growth spurt and want to nurse around the clock, and this is normal, and done to increase your milk supply, so don’t worry much about it, your baby will be fussier than usual, but after about 24 hours it will pass, and your supply will increase to meet your baby’s demands.  Something like that.  Good, sound advice, right??  Nevertheless, when it actually happened to our own adorable son, I was so unprepared and blown away by it that I feel like we really need to make a bigger deal about this.  Babies need to come with a WARNING label that reads something like this:

Dear Parents, I am your brand new, wonderful baby. I have very simple needs, but I cannot communicate them to you, therefore, I am a mystery.  I also am changing very rapidly, and every day will be different.  I promise you–DIFFERENT.  Make no assumptions, there are no patterns, just when you think you know who I am and what I like, I will CHANGE.  Oh, and let me tell you about my first growth spurt. It will happen sometime when I am 2-3 weeks old, and it will come out of nowhere, like a bolt of lightning.  Up until my growth spurt, I may have been a good nurser.  You may have been banking on me sleeping at least 2 hour stretches at a time. You may have thought you had figured out what kind of bouncing or rocking or swaying or singing I enjoyed.  You may have been gaining some confidence with your new parenting skills. HAH! I am here to tell you that my growth spurt will throw all of this out the window. It won’t just throw it out the window, it will toss it up, spit on it, tear it to shreds, set fire to the shreds, and then throw the ashes out the window all done while laughing maniacally.  During my growth spurt, I will DEMAND food every hour, on the hour, and when you offer me your breasts, I will flail at them and spit them out because they will be EMPTY and so inadequate for my growing needs.  I will not just be fussier than usual, I will be INCONSOLABLE.  I will introduce you to several of my more distressing cries which I have been saving for just this occasion: the high-pitched wail, the piercing shriek, the crying-so-hard-I-choke-and-stop-breathing-for-awhile, the so-red-in-the-face-you’ll-think-you-need-to-call-911—these and other specialty cries I prepared for you.  I will not let you sleep. AT ALL. EVER.  You might have thought other parents were just joking when they said they literally got NO sleep, but really, TRULY, you WILL NOT SLEEP.  You will spend 24 hours trying to comfort me.  You will pull your hair out. You will wonder where you can return me to.  You will question the decision you made to have a baby.  You will question whey you ever wanted to have sex, ever, in your life, instead of joining a convent at the tender age of 13.  You will be forced to watch an all-night Hugh Grant movie marathon in bleary sleep-deprivation while I gnaw and masticate your nipples to a pulp in my unending demand for milk, of which you are so unable to provide for me.  And then, finally, when I pass out from exhaustion after wailing for 8 hours, I will only sleep for 2 hours before beginning the cycle all over again.  THIS IS MY GROWTH SPURT!  BE AFRAID! BE VERY AFRAID!

In other words, the next time I tell other women about the growth spurt, I will try a little bit harder to prepare them for it. Not that anything can really prepare a new parent for it, but I will, indeed, make a bigger deal about it.  And, for the record, we did survive.  It wasn’t quite 24 hours, more like 36, but now, on the other side of it, I can vouch for the fact that your milk supply does catch up, remarkably quickly, and normal nursing does resume again, about a day later.  But honestly, new parents, be on the lookout for the growth spurt—it is truly no joke!!!

Posted in Babies! | Leave a comment

My Birth Story

It’s funny to be writing this.  I have heard and listened to so many women share their birth stories with me, posted birth stories here on my blog, attended births and helped women write their birth stories, but now I come to a first for me: the writing of my own birth story.  I think there’s something really important about writing your birth story down, for so many reasons.  First, it helps you process something which is almost too big to process, too mysterious and transformational and ephemeral; writing it down helps capture it in a way that can be recalled.  It turns it into a story, something which can be retold and remembered, something which can be shared with others, something which can take on mythic qualities the more you share it.  It can offer guidance or inspiration (if it’s a positive story) or confirm fears and doubts (if it’s a negative story); it becomes part of the framework that women use to understand birth, and I believe that the sharing and retelling of these stories if vital for women, and a very important part of the postpartum healing process.

So, without further adieu…

Labor for me started on Saturday May 14th.  I was 39 weeks and 2 days pregnant, and was very ready to give birth.  I had stopped working at 38 weeks, and had spent the last week finishing up the few small things on my to-do list, but mostly I spent it resting and reading my novel, getting a last pre-birth pedicure, catching up with friends, and waiting, waiting, waiting.  Wondering when it was going to start, when I would go into labor, what labor would be like, how long or short or awful or ecstatic it would be…

It was the contractions that woke me up around 4 am on Saturday morning.  They were like really strong menstrual cramps, too painful to sleep through, although I tried to sleep in between them (but also I was really excited that things were starting, so I didn’t sleep much).  Around 9 am I woke my husband up and we started to time them a bit: they were still irregular, every 8-10 min, and stayed that way through most of the day.  At points they even spaced out and almost went away completely. I went to brunch with some of my colleagues from work around 1 pm, and during the whole of brunch my contractions disappeared completely. After brunch we got some ice cream and walked around a bit, and the walking brought them back again. Feeling like something was finally happening, we picked up some last minute baby stuff (diapers!) and headed home.  The contractions continued through the afternoon, strong enough to make napping difficult, and then I lost my mucus plug around 6 pm that night, which I took as a really good sign, and we ordered some pizza for dinner and tried to watch a movie while I rocked on the birthing ball.  The contractions continued to pick up pace, and about halfway through the movie I told my husband I couldn’t concentrate on the movie any more.  We turned the movie off, and called our doula.  At this point, the contractions were about every 4-5 min, and were starting to take up all of my attention, which again we thought was a good sign.

Our wonderful doula came over around midnight Sat. night, and we bounced on the ball for awhile, and then walked and swayed with the contractions, while they continued very strong and intense every 4-5 min.  I thought this was active labor, and believe me, they really were strong and painful contractions!  We called our midwife, and she came over around two am on Sunday morning. (Just a quick word about our midwives: we had two midwives who would be attending our birth.  The first midwife to show up was the one who was actually on-call that weekend).  We also called my best friend, who lives 10 blocks away and was going to act as an assistant/ extra pair of hands throughout the birth (her main role was to keep my husband hydrated, and to take pictures).  I would blow or moan throw the contractions, and my husband and our doula did a great job of keeping me hydrated and eating small snacks now and then, and getting me up to the bathroom to pee every hour or so.  At some point, I got into the birth tub and labored there for several hours.  I felt nauseous and thought I needed to vomit, which got us very excited because we thought we were hitting transition.  How wrong we were!!

As the light came up on Sunday morning I was about 26 hours into labor (counting from 4 am on Saturday, which is when the contractions had first begun), and I was getting incredibly exhausted.  Our midwife finally checked me around 6 am to see where I was at, and it turned out I was only 4 cm dilated!!  And not a loose and stretchy 4 cm, a tight and unstretchy 4 cm, and only about 80% effaced!  I can’t even begin to describe my disappointment at this point.  I had thought I had been going through strong active labor, and here I was still in early labor, more or less, after all of that hard work!   Our midwife gave us a pep talk: the longest part of labor is the latent phase, I was now 4 cm which is pretty much the end of latent phase and a great place to start from, the baby’s heart had always sounded perfect every time we had listened to him, so he was holding up well, and everything was still looking good.  We decided to re-set and take a rest.  I was truly exhausted, and knowing where I was in the labor was helpful, at least, because it gave me perspective.  Our midwife went home to get a nap, our doula and friend fell asleep on our couch, and my husband and I went to bed.  Every time I had a contraction I just kept telling myself it was nothing, no big deal, and to relax, thinking that if I was only 4 cm dilated, these contractions weren’t the real deal, and shouldn’t take up so much of my attention.  With this mindset I was able to sleep for about 2 hours, and the contractions mercifully spaced out quite a bit.

I woke up around 9:30 am on Sunday morning and headed upstairs again. Our doula woke up and cooked some breakfast for us (mmm, pancakes–although I was only able to eat a few bites), and we began our second day of labor.  It was a strange mix of hope and fear.  I was hopeful because I had made it to 4 cm, which meant that something was happening, and that every contraction after that was hopefully dilating me further.  But I was also doubtful and full of fear, unsure if things were actually progressing or not.  My midwife brain was still very active, thinking about possible scenarios and what-if situations: what if I didn’t dilate any further? What if I was too exhausted to go on? What if I was the same at the next exam? Then what?  I read aloud a long list of birth affirmations which I had written during the pregnancy, and we listened to some powerful Goddess chants while I labored on the ball, and eventually we took a walk around the block, just to get some fresh air.  Our midwife had left the birth set-up at our house, and since our doula was also a Labour & Delivery RN, we periodically checked the fetal heart beat throughout the day with the doppler, and his heart continued to chug along nice and steady, 120s-130s, which was very reassuring.  At least he was doing well, even if his mama was languishing!  The contractions continued pretty regularly every 4-5 minutes throughout most of the day, but by late afternoon they had begun to peter out again, and I was beyond exhausted at this point. I had more or less decided in my mind that the next step was going to be heading in to the hospital for an epidural and pitocin, because I was truly beginning to feel like I couldn’t take it any more.

The first on-call midwife came back over late Sunday afternoon around 4 pm and at that point I was very business-like.  I wanted an exam, and I wanted to know what the next step was.  She checked me and, much to my despair, I was only 4-5 cm dilated, although now it was a very stretchy and loose 4-5 cm, and She was able to manually stretch and dilate my cervix to 6 cm (which was EXCRUCIATING), and I’m not even sure if it stayed that way because his head wasn’t well-applied to the cervix at that point.  We talked through our options once again. I mentioned the epidural and pitocin idea, but everyone else felt this was premature. It was a moment where my birth team had more faith in my power to birth than I did, and I am so grateful to them for their strength and perseverance, because I was losing faith in myself!  Our midwife suggested trying some nipple stimulation instead of pitocin.  So once again we re-set, and tried to change the energy in the room.  We put on a mix of some of my favorite hip-hop and rap songs with a strong and powerful beat, and I began to move more vigorously, doing squats and lunges during the contractions.  In between contractions we stimulated my nipples with a breast pump while I rocked my hips back and forth in time to the music.

After another few hours of this, I was once again exhausted and losing faith and the contractions, despite the nipple stimulation, were petering out once more.  At this point the second midwife came over and we had a very long heart-to-heart conversation about all of our options. I was about ready to throw in the towel; I was practically convinced that going to the hospital was the only way out of this situation. Instead, the second midwife went through all of the positives with me: the baby’s heart was strong and he was doing well, so there was no concern about fetal distress, my membranes were still intact so there was no risk of infection, and slow labors are still normal labors.  We also talked about my fears at this point.  My biggest fear was simply that I couldn’t do it; that giving birth vaginally, at home, no less, was beyond me.  I was scared that I had watched it happen for so many other women, but that somehow now that it was my turn it wasn’t going to work for me. After all, I hadn’t given birth yet—how did I know if I could actually do it or not?  She told me that what I needed was sleep more than anything, and that my body would probably naturally pick up where it had left off when it was better rested and ready to continue.  This midwife had over 25 years of experience, and had been attending homebirths for over 12 years, and when she spoke it was with the wise voice of experience, which I found incredibly reassuring.  She told me a few stories about other homebirths she had attended which had also lasted for days and days, and reminded me that there was no Freidman Curve in a homebirth (i.e there was no ticking clock hanging over us)!  Even though she hadn’t been attending most of the labor so far, speaking with her was just what we needed at a very crucial point in the labor.

So we took a second nap break (around 8 pm on May 15th) with the assistance of lots of hydration and a glass of wine, which went straight to my head given that I had hardly eaten during the labor, and I hadn’t been drinking alcohol for the preceding nine months.  The contractions spaced out a bit and I was able to get some rest.  Everyone took a break, actually; our doula and good friend both headed home, and the midwives gathered up all of the birth equipment and left as well.  I was hoping I would be able to sleep for 4-5 hours, and half expected to wake up around 2 am, which was the time our midwife had randomly suggested the labor might restart.  Instead, while only an hour and half into my nap, I was awakened by shockingly strong contractions, much stronger than anything that had come before.  I moaned my way through a couple of them, and then around 10:30 pm I had three MONSTER contractions in a row which needed more than mere moaning to get through them. I had also begun to shake uncontrollably, and my teeth were chattering.  I couldn’t stop the shaking and shivering in between the contractions, and I was feeling very panicked because the contractions were suddenly so strong, and so close together.  I couldn’t even get out of bed before the next one hit me, and I couldn’t stop shivering and chattering.  I was also hot at the same time, and sweating profusely. It was a very strange combination.  I woke my husband up out of a dead sleep and told him to call our doula and the midwife ASAP, because I was frightened and I didn’t know what was going on.  He went upstairs and wisely called our doula first (but not the midwife), who hopped in a cab and came back over even though she had only been home for 3 hours.  While we were waiting for her to get to our house, he helped me out of bed and got me upstairs, where I spent my time clinging to the railing by the stairs while moaning and shivering through contraction after contraction.  They were every three minutes at this point, and I was finally (finally!!) in booming, active labor.

Our doula arrived and I stopped feeling so panicky, although the shivering and sweating and teeth chattering continued.  The contractions felt out of control, so much stronger than anything that had come before!  I also vomited for real this time, but I was too deep into the labor to even comment on it, although the thought that this was a good sign did flash through my mind briefly.  My husband and our doula re-filled the birth tub, and I got into it for the second time, which took about an hour.  During that time I stayed on the ball for the most part.  I also got up to go to the bathroom, too, and ended up having a few contractions on the toilet, which felt like water torture!  There was so much more pressure while on the toilet, and I remember clutching the side of the sink with both hands and feeling like I was about to pass out from the pain.  Everything was so stark and bright in the bathroom, the white of the porcelain sink was so white, the pain was so sharp!  Thankfully, the birth tub was full soon after that, and I was able to get into the merciful, soothing warm water.  In the tub I was on my hands and knees during contractions, clinging to the grips on the side of the tub (or my husband) for dear life and moaning my head off, while in between I was able to more or less float on my back and sleep for 3-4 minutes.  The tub didn’t really make the contractions easier to bear, but it allowed me to completely relax in between contractions to the point that I could sleep, which was so important because I was so exhausted.

I had also become completely non-verbal, barely able to respond to folks and sleeping in between contractions.  The most I could do was say “gatorade” every now and then when I was thirsty, and wave my hand in front of my face, which either meant “fan me” or “stop!” if someone was touching or doing something which was painful or annoying.  My husband proved invaluable in interpreting what these different signals meant.  In retrospect there was such a clear difference between the labor at this point and the labor which had preceded it.  During the whole of Saturday night and Sunday day, even though the contractions had been strong and regular and intense, I was still alert and communicative in between contractions, talking to folks, even cracking jokes now and then.  During the active phase, Sunday night into Monday morning, there was no communication in between contractions. I was dead asleep, and responding to the contractions instinctively, 100% in my monkey brain, as Ina May would say.  My birth team was also pretty much dead asleep.  I remember opening my eyes briefly in between a contraction to see both my doula and husband resting on the edge of the tub with their heads on their arms.  Time had no meaning.  We would sleep in between contractions, mobilize for the contraction itself, and then fall asleep again as soon as the contraction was over.  I remember thinking that the contractions were terrible—just TERRIBLE—but that all I had to do was get through the contraction and then I could return to the delicious sleep state which was thankfully much longer than the contraction itself.  There was still a lot of residual pain after the contractions, though, and my birth team did a great job of reminding me to relax my shoulders, my face, my jaw in between, and return to a restful state.  My best friend arrived again at some point during this time, but honestly, I can’t even remember when.  I remember looking up and seeing her there, watching me, and I said “hi” briefly, then I was back in it again.

The first on-call midwife arrived on the scene around 2 am again Monday morning, lugging all of her birth equipment with her.  I was anxious to be checked, because I felt that surely (surely!) I must be progressing, and I was hoping that I was close to fully dilated.  We also listened to the baby’s heart again, and there he was, chugging along like usual, strong and steady with a fetal heart rate of 120s-130s. Unfortunately, I was not quite fully, but I was thankfully 8 cm dilated (woo-hoo!!!), and at this point I was too deep into labor to think much about it.  It was all I could do to stay on top of the contractions, which were still every 3-4 minutes, and beyond huge and intense.  At some point after this, the nature of the pain began to change, and I found myself wanting to bear down with it every now and then. Instead of moaning or blowing with the contraction, I would find myself involuntarily holding my breath and grunting.

After another hour of this, I was beginning to feel like I would be in labor forever.  I had forgotten why I was in labor.  I could only think about the contractions, which felt like they had been happening since the dawn of time, and would continue indefinitely.  I think I had even asked for an epidural a few times, or asked to just be put out of my misery, which my birth team wisely ignored (although afterwards they admitted to giving each other “high-five” looks with their eyes during these comments).  I was thinking that even a cesarean didn’t sound like such a bad idea, if it would only take the pain away, although I didn’t say this aloud.  Finally, completely exasperated and feeling like I would never be fully dilated, I reached down and checked myself to see what was going on, and to my immense relief, I could actually feel his head low in my pelvis, just sitting there, on the verge of being born, with only a thin lip of cervix in the way.  It was such an incredible feeling!  During my self exam I said aloud, to the midwife: “anterior lip, +1, bulging bag” which made perfect sense to me and her, but which absolutely mystified my husband.  Afterwards, he said he couldn’t believe that in the middle of labor—in the middle of a contraction—I was able to say something like “anterior lip”.  But that’s what I was feeling, and I was so thankful to be almost finished with the first stage of labor!  I also can’t describe how amazing it was to feel something which I had felt so often in other women during labor actually occurring inside of me—my own body and baby on the verge of delivery!  It was such an amazing feeling that I reached down to feel it again after a few more contractions, and this time there was an internal pop feeling, and my own bag of waters broke.  Suddenly I was sitting in a pool of vernix, but the fluid was clear, which was a very good sign.  The midwife asked if I had popped it on purpose, but I hadn’t!  It had happened on its own, spontaneous rupture of membranes at 3:55 am on May 16th.

Once the water broke, I began to feel a lot of rectal pressure (the “grapefruit in anus” feeling which we had joked about during our childbirth class), and my body began to bear down with the contractions, but it was so painful!!  I kept shying away from actually pushing with the contractions, even though my body was trying to, because the pushing felt absolutely excruciating! After a few more attempts at pushing in the tub, someone suggested I get out of the tub and try pushing on dry land (I’m not sure who suggested this…or even if I was the one who suggested it?)  It felt like the tub was too relaxing, though, and it was too easy to run from the pain of pushing, instead of facing it and beginning this very different kind of very hard work.  So with assistance I got out of the tub and lumbered over to the futon we had set up in the living room, complete with plastic sheet and two layers of cheap polyester sheets on top, perfect for getting mucky and bloody.  Our midwife re-checked me one more time at this point, and I still had the small lip of cervix in front of the baby’s head, so with her assistance I pushed through two contractions while she held the lip out of the way, and after two unbearably painful contractions I was finally (finally!) fully dilated.

I was half expecting that pushing would go pretty quickly, because I had it somewhere in the back of my head that I would be a good pusher.  Instead, my birth once again humbled me and taught me a different lesson.  Pushing ended up taking 4 hours, although I wasn’t really aware of the passage of time because it was so intense, and because I felt that he was on the verge of being born with every push, and then the next push, and then the push after that.  I finally couldn’t run away from the pushing, but had to embrace it—the only way out was through.  My body was pushing so powerfully with every contraction, doing this completely on its own.  It was as if I were constipated with the largest poop of my life, and my body was bound and determined to push it out against my will.  So when the contraction started, I curled up on my side while my midwife or doula held one leg, and then I would squeeze my stomach muscles and strain with the contraction, trying to move the grapefruit down little by little.  At first I felt like I was making no progress at all, but everyone began to say very encouraging things, and I could tell from their tone of voice that they felt I was doing a good job, even though I felt like he was stuck and going nowhere.  And we pushed. And pushed. And pushed.  When the contraction came, I grabbed whatever was closest to me in a fearsome grip and squeezed for dear life—usually this was my husband’s hand, or shoulder, or shirt, or leg, or hip.  He was curled up on the futon at my head, and I kept flopping back into his lap in between the contractions, still dead asleep in between the pushing.  It’s hard to actually remember this part, because my eyes were closed almost the entire time, and I was so internally focused on my body.  I do remember opening my eyes at some point and marveling that it had gotten light out—I couldn’t believe so much time had passed!  To me it felt like it was still only 2 or 3 in the morning, in the deep dark of the night.

I do remember reaching down at one point and feeling his head beginning to present—he felt so huge and bulging in my rectum, but all I could feel was a tiny quarter-sized bit of head between my legs, and I remember shrieking: “that’s it???”  Compared to how everyone had been encouraging me, and compared to how low and full he felt, I thought he was nearly out of me.  But everyone continued to encourage me, and my body kept giving me no choice, so I kept pushing.  And pushing. And pushing.  Our second midwife had come back over again at some point (probably once I was fully and pushing, although I don’t remember when she came), and she kept fanning me and making sure I had sips of Gatorade in between pushes.  She really wanted to be there for the delivery, but there was another woman in labor at the same time, and her labor was going very quickly, so unfortunately, even though our second midwife kept trying to put it off, she had to leave to attend the other birth, and I ended up delivering with the first on-call midwife, which actually felt very appropriate since she had been there through the bulk of the labor with us.

I tried pushing in a few other positions (hands and knees, kneeling), but the side-lying position seemed to be working the best, so we stuck with that for the majority of the time.  Honestly, I’m not sure where I found the strength to do it—it was more like I was on a runaway train and there was no way to get off, so I had to just keep going, and pushing with every contraction because I had no choice.  Finally, he began to crown, and everyone kept reassuring me that he was finally under the pubic bone and wasn’t slipping back into my pelvis in between pushes, and that they could see more and more of his head.  They offered me a mirror so that I could actually see him coming out with each push, but I didn’t want to look.  It was easier just to feel, and amazingly, when I reached down I could feel his little head just sitting there between my legs—with so much downy soft hair on his head!  Great, I thought, it will be soon! And I let myself begin to believe, truly believe, that I was going to give birth vaginally in my home, soon.  But he continued to crown, and crown, and crown, and even though I was pushing incredibly strong with every contraction, I couldn’t seem to actually get him out.

My midwife tried to apply some warm compresses to my perineum, which felt okay, although sometimes too hot.  She also tried to do some perineal massage, but this was way too painful to tolerate, so I eventually snapped at her to keep her hands off.  I could also, incredibly, feel him squirming his little head around inside of me, trying to find the perfect fit through my pelvis.  I thought it was the midwife touching me again, and I told her again not to touch me, but she assured me it was the baby, she was keeping her hands off.  It got to the point that I couldn’t even tell when I was contracting anymore, because everything had become so painful.  The midwives were listening to the baby’s heart every other push at this point, and even having the Doppler pressing against my skin right about the pubic bone was excruciating.  As soon as I heard his heart, I kept trying to get them to take the Doppler away as quickly as possible, although they wanted to listen for longer than just a second.  But I could feel the baby moving inside of me, and I knew that everything was fine with him—there was no way I could communicate this to the birth team, so generally it amounted to them listening to his heart while I moaned and waved my hand and tried to get them to take the Doppler away.  I began to feel the “ring of fire”, which truly was a ring of fire, so painful that every time I got to that point, it was very hard to push past it.  And since I could hardly tell when I was contracting anymore, my husband began to count down for me, and I would push with him when he told me to push.  It felt as if I were turning my insides out.  Our midwife finally suggested that I get into a kneeling position for the last few pushes, and with some effort I was able to turn myself over with a baby half sticking out of me, and I knelt on my knees and leaned on against my husband’s chest for the last few pushes.

Suddenly the midwife told to my husband to come look, quick, and I could finally (finally!) feel the baby slipping out of me, through the ring of fire.  It happened so quickly, after such a long push, that it was hard to believe it was finally over.  The midwife passed the baby up between my legs towards me, and there he was: pink and wet and screaming, waving his little arms and legs, looking completely outraged!  I had thought I would cry with joy when I first saw him, but honestly, my first thought was: oh thank the gods he’s out!!!!!

They put the baby on my chest and I eased myself back into a sitting position, and we all just marveled over how amazing and beautiful our son was.  Slowly, slowly it began to sink in that the labor was over, and there was a baby in my arms!

Within a few minutes (seemed that way at least, since time had stopped), the midwife said the placenta was just sitting there, and that I needed to give a few pushes.  I was so exhausted, and pushing felt so painful that I’m not even sure I was any help at all, but I did hold my breath and grunt a few times, and the placenta slipped out between my legs, and it was finally over!  I couldn’t care less about the placenta, though—I was too busy marveling over our baby.  But suddenly the midwife, who had been inspecting the placenta, gasped and told me to take a look at it.  Instead of a normal cord insertion, where the three blood vessels of the cord insert into the body of the placenta directly, our baby had something called a velamentous cord insertion, which occurs when the blood vessels insert into the membranes instead of the placenta directly, and aren’t protected by the wharton’s jelly.  It happens in about 1% of all pregnancies, so it’s pretty rare, and also very fragile and delicate, and isn’t seen on sonogram (usually).  If anything had happened to one of those tiny vessels during the delivery, it could have been catastrophic.  I had actually encountered a similar cord insertion several years ago when I was working as a L&D nurse, and we actually lost that baby—during the pushing phase the baby had descended very rapidly, and had torn one of the vessels on the way down, and we even though we had rushed the mother and baby back to the OR when the fetal heart rate dropped and didn’t recover, we hadn’t been fast enough.

So in the end, I feel like I had the perfect birth—the exact birth that my baby and I had needed.  Suddenly, in light of my placenta, my slow, protracted labor made a lot more sense, as did the four hours of pushing, where he descended at a snail’s pace, slow and steady.  Every time we had listened to his heart, he had sounded strong and healthy, without a single deceleration or indication that anything was wrong.  I also think that my labor had to wear me down to the point that I was so exhausted I couldn’t think any more.  During the whole of Saturday and most of Sunday, I had still been in my brain far too much, still been thinking about everything too much, still too much of a midwife and not enough of a laboring woman.  It wasn’t until I was utterly exhausted, 41 hours into labor, that my mind finally turned off, and my body could take over.  Once that happened, once my mind was finally out of the way and my monkey brain was running the show, then suddenly the labor progressed pretty quickly.  41 hours of latent phase, 11 hours of active phase, 4 hours of pushing, and one beautiful, perfect son (and an intact perineum!!).  And I’m so grateful that I was allowed to labor at home, with a birth team that totally, 100% believed in me and the power of my body!  I am fairly certain that if I had been in a hospital, the clock would have started ticking at some point, and steps would have been taken to move things along–an epidural and pitocin, or maybe even a cesarean for “failure to progress.”  Probably at the point on Sunday when I was still only 4-5 cm dilated after over 36 hours of labor.  In general, I feel like most hospitals, and most providers aren’t as patient as mine had been, or so certain in their belief that labor is a normal, healthy process, and that long, marathon labors can still be normal too.  And then who knows what would have happened to our baby if we had been forcing things to move more quickly–if the pitocin had brought him down too quickly, or distressed him in some other way, especially given his fragile cord insertion.  It’s all in the realm of what might have been, thankfully.  What actually happened was just what needed to happen, and my beautiful son was born at home into the loving arms of his family.

Because of its rarity, and because this is a midwife’s blog, I am posting a picture of the placenta here, behind the “More” link.  WARNING: placenta alert! Not for the squeamish! But check out the velamentous cord insertion: pretty fascinating (from an academic point of view):

Read More »

Posted in Birth Stories, Good Enough to Share, Homebirth, Labor and Birth, Vaginal Birth | 1 Comment

The Obstetrician’s Lament

There is an astounding collection of writing going up on The Unnecesarean regarding the growing rift between obstetricians and the out-of-hospital birth community.  All of this is in response to the The Obstetrician’s Lament, written by OB-GYN Anette Fineberg, MD, which came out in the May edition of ACOG’s Green Journal (Obstetrics and Gynecology).  I will post the full text of “The Obstetrician’s Lament” here, (courtesy of Navelgazing Midwife) since most readers here will not have a subscription to ACOG:

A few weeks ago, during a prenatal visit, a woman pregnant with twins told me she would love to have a home birth, but did not have the $4,000 cash required upfront to do so. She was afraid of potential interventions in the hospital. After a discussion of her fears as well as potential complications that can abruptly occur in a twin birth, she admitted she would prefer a hospital birth if she could maintain some control over the situation. This is not a woman who cares more about the birth experience than the baby, but she was tempted, and in some ways I can understand her concerns. My cousin’s wife had her twin induction halted at 4 cm because the new obstetrician on call did not do breech extractions for second twins. Her only option became cesarean delivery.

I recently received a phone call from a woman 2 hours away who had planned a home birth for her second baby after having an easy first birth. When the fetus, which was anticipated to be a little smaller, was found to be a breech, the midwife sent the woman to the local obstetricians. They would only deliver the fetus by cesarean delivery. The midwife offered the woman a home breech birth, but admitted she had only delivered one breech (stillbirth) in her career. The woman appropriately questioned the safety of this, and was referred to us. She met the criteria for our vaginal breech protocol, and had an easy vaginal breech birth in our hospital. Unfortunately, this is becoming a rarity. A colleague of mine in another state watched the residents she was supervising emotionally bully a young woman and her mother into a cesarean delivery. The young woman had a rapidly progressing active labor with a normal-sized frank breech fetus. Had the residents been open to the idea, my colleague easily could have taught them how to deliver a vaginal breech.

The running joke in our community is that the only way to get a vaginal birth after cesarean delivery (VBAC) is to have the birth at home. Unfortunately, this is a reality rather than a joke. Our small community hospital, owing to regional liability insurance constraints, stopped allowing VBACs in 2002 after many years of  successfully offering them. This has led many women to risk home birth rather than travel to a tertiary care center to attempt VBAC. I recently counseled a woman against having a cesarean delivery who had a BMI of 52 and who arrived in active labor at over 35 weeks of gestation with two previous successful VBACs. I spent the following months defending that recommendation, despite her considerable operative risks and high likelihood of success.

Recent news and media excitement about the benefits and increased safety of home birth over hospital birth have made the former seem like a very attractive alternative. A growing notion among women in our region, and perhaps across the country, is that hospitals and obstetricians are a more risky option than lay-home midwives for birth. Although my initial reaction is disbelief, perhaps we should look at how we, the  obstetricians, contribute to this trend.

Each of these women deserves an honest discussion about the fetal and maternal risks of each birthing option. However, our lack of experience as obstetricians colored by our fear of liability is narrowing women’s choices, and sometimes motivating them to ignore fetal and maternal safety in an effort not to be coerced into unnecessary interventions. I sense a mounting tension, because many obstetricians do not have the willingness, time, or skills to provide maternal choices.

I believe we are at a crossroad in maternity care in this country, and I am saddened that obstetricians are considered the culprits. Our contracting skill set as obstetric providers, as well as the prevailing risk-adverse culture among physicians and hospitals, have given support to home birth. We can all agree that VBAC, twins, and breech should not be managed at home, yet we frequently demand complete control of the situation and eliminate some appropriate choices in the hospital. I understand that it can be very unnerving to be ultimately responsible for the outcome, as we are, and yet pushed into situations outside of our comfort zones. However, our unwillingness to budge in these situations is causing us to lose the battle regarding what is really important to most obstetricians: safety for mothers and babies.

Certainly, we can be proud of the dramatic decrease in maternal mortality in the last century. But, despite the highest per capita expenditure of health care in the world, infant and maternal mortality rates in the United States are higher than in all of western Europe. We have the third-highest cesarean delivery rate in the world.

According to a recent study, nearly half of all primigravidas attempting vaginal delivery are induced, and half of cesarean deliveries for dystocia are done before 6 cm of dilation, presumably before active labor. It is amazing how many women begging for elective induction change their minds when told it doubles their cesarean  delivery risk.

We need to draw lines around patient safety, but must they be so rigid? Most midwives know from experience that Friedman’s curve is too strict. A recent study validates that knowledge. I sincerely hope it is taken seriously. Expectant management of ruptured membranes at term has been declared unsafe and of no benefit. The study that settled the question did not account for the number of vaginal examinations women received, and group B strep was not treated, both important variables. Most women do go into labor in 24 to 72 hours. The Cochrane systematic review concludes that, because the differences in outcome are not substantial, women need to be given the appropriate information to make a decision. This very rarely occurs in the hospital setting. The Term Breech Study closed the door on vaginal breech delivery even for the lowest-risk women in most obstetricians’ minds (including the residents I mentioned above). This, despite the opinion of the College that it may be appropriate in carefully selected situations. In any case, vaginal breech delivery is not completely avoidable, and should not be relegated to the history books with vaginal delivery for previa and high forceps.

Our mission has become more difficult in the last 20 years as mothers have become older, heavier, and of lower parity. Many women, admittedly, do have unrealistic expectations. Although I am eternally grateful for the obstetric skills I learned in residency, I have been amazed in my 14 years of practice to see much of the dogma I also absorbed disproven with experience and patience (both my own, my colleagues’, and the midwives I have worked with in the hospital setting). Collaborative practice with midwives is a good start, but in order for obstetricians to be more than providers of cesarean deliveries (a thankless and, in most cases, technically simple procedure) we need to have conversations with our patients that are not one sided and allow for true informed consent. Many of the obstetric disasters we have all seen and which color our  perspective (which David Grimes has called “numerators in search of denominators”) are at least in some part iatrogenic if examined deeply enough. That failed induction for convenience with early artificial rupture of  membranes and chorioamnionitis. The first cesarean delivery done at age 15 after 2 hours of pushing with an epidural that then leads to the fifth cesarean years later, and then accreta and life-threatening hemorrhage, are both typical examples. We need to recognize and own those aspects of obstetric management that are driving our skyrocketing cesarean delivery rate but having no positive effect on maternal or infant morbidity and mortality.

Admitting what is truly evidence based versus what is tradition and culture is a good start. It is essential that we offer real choices to our patients. We need to recover and disseminate the skills that make obstetrics an art and a privilege. Seek out mentors skilled in forceps, vaginal breeches, and breech extractions before it is too late. Then learn to be patient, so that you very rarely need to use them

I find this letter to be very brave and commendable, and while this may sound strange, I am actually really proud of ACOG for publishing it in the first place.  Kudos to Dr. Fineberg for writing this, especially given that she may very well experience a backlash from her colleagues for even suggesting that VBACs, vaginal breech deliveries and vaginal twin deliveries (with breech extraction for the second twin) are things which OBs should be offering their clients, let alone her suggestion that OBs may be partially responsible for driving women with complications to seek homebirth in the first place.

Even more fascinating to me, though, are the commentaries which are going up on The Unnecesarean right now, all written by a collection of different obstetricians who are willing to step forth and give their unvarnished opinion on the true state of things (and huge kudos to them, as well!).  Here are links to their articles:

Lamenting the System, by Dr. Jill Arnold

Lament in Stereo, by Dr. Lauren A. Plante

A Comeback for VBAC?, by Dr. Poppy Daniels

Another Obstetrician’s Lament, by Dr. Gustavo San Roman

An Obstetrician’s Hope, by Dr. David Hayes

The VBAC comments I found particularly compelling, given the sorry state of VBACs in this country right now (see my post below on the new NIH Consensus Guidelines).  The sad truth is, VBACs are no longer being offered as a viable option simply because of politics and a growing culture of fear (aided by our culture of litigation) which states that just because uterine rupture is (occasionally, super rarely) possible, there needs to be 24-hour on-call anesthesia, and an obstetrician on-call ready to brandish a knife at the drop of a hat…and because of this (occasional, super rare) risk, it’s better to not offer VBACs if you don’t have these emergency measures in place.  Nevermind the increasing risks associated with repeat cesareans, the growing rate of cesarean complications, placenta percreta/ acreta etc. etc.  But Dr. Poppy Daniels has addressed this on The Unecessarean more eloquently than I have time to right now, so I’ll let you follow the links.

Besides, I have much more exciting news to share! Stay tuned for a very personal birth story, coming up next!

 

 

Posted in Cesarean Birth, Complications, Hospitals, Journal Articles, Labor and Birth, Politics, VBAC | Leave a comment

Blessingway Poetry

I also wanted to share the two poems which were read at my Blessingway, because they are so beautiful, and even now, just reading them will bring tears to my eyes.

Mother Wisdom Speaks

by Christine Lore Webber

Some of you I will hollow out.
I will make you a cave.
I will carve you so deep the stars will shine in your darkness.
You will be a bowl.
You will be the cup in the rock collecting rain.
I will hollow you with knives. 

I will not do this to make you clean.
I will not do this to make you pure.
You are clean already.
You are pure already.

I will do this because the world needs the hollowness of you.
I will do this for the space that you will be.
I will do this because you must be large.
A passage.
People will find their way through you.
A bowl.
People will eat from you
and their hunger will not weaken them to death.
A cup to catch the sacred rain.

My daughter, do not cry. Do not be afraid.
Nothing you need will be lost.
I am shaping you.
I am making you ready.
Light will flow in your hollowing.
You will be filled with light.
Your bones will shine.
The round open center of you will be radiant.
I will call you Brilliant One.
I will call you Daughter Who is Wide.
I will call you transformed.

———————————————————————————————————-

Chant of the Pregnant Goddess

by Jana McCarthy 

I am the mother of the moon
sister of the stars
child of the light in your eyes.
I am powerful.

The geometry of my shape shifts
from gently curved lines
to expanding circles:
earth, moon, sun.

I am powerful.
I am strong.

The tempo of my vibration quickens,
increasing from
butterfly wings, to floundering fish,
to beating drum,
erupting volcano,
the rhythm as old and constant as
the cycles of the sun
and the turn of the tides.

I am powerful.
I am strong.
I am beautiful.

I hold the hope of my ancestors
the knowledge of my time
the fate of my future.

I am powerful.
I am strong.
I am beautiful.
I am mother.

Posted in Birth Art, Labor and Birth, Myth, Folklore and Ritual | Leave a comment

The Waiting is the Hardest Part

I feel like I need to be singing the Tom Petty tune right now…

39 weeks pregnant now, everything is ready.  Our fridge is full of food and drinks (gatorade, coconut water) for the birth. The birth tub has been inflated and set up close to the bathroom, ready to be filled. I’ve prepped postpartum pads with witch-hazel and stashed them in the freezer so they’ll be nice and icy-cold for sore postpartum perineums.  The diaper changing area and co-sleeper are set up and waiting. The birth kit is in the corner, with its attendant sheets/ towels/ washcloths/ plastic drapes/ shower curtains etc.  We have a birth ball.  And a rocking chair.  A moby, a baby bjorn, newborn clothes washed and folded and tucked away in dresser drawers.  We have everything except actual contractions…

It’s the strangest thing, this state of limbo.  I stopped working last week, at 38 weeks, which was a relief because work was becoming very difficult.  Two weeks ago, at 37 weeks, I attended a birth with a four-hour push at the end of it, and although I never doubted that the woman would be able to push her baby out, I did doubt if I would have the strength to get through it, heavily-pregnant and tired as I was. In the end, another midwife from our practice came in and helped assist during the last hour or so of the pushing, because my energy was really flagging.  And at some point, as a pregnant woman, you begin to want to focus all of your energy inward, on yourself and your baby, and it feels very hard to take that energy and give it to other women in labor.  Not that I’m being selfish about my energy, but I have reached the point where my own pregnancy is becoming paramount, and taking up more space in my head and heart than my midwife-self.   At which point I’m not much of a service to other women in labor anymore.  The time has come to be just a pregnant woman now.

And these last few days which have been given to me are wonderful. Days when I can still lounge around, stop by the nail salon and get a pedicure just because I have the time and the inclination.  Nights where I can sleep as long as I like (broken only by getting up to pee 3-4x/night).  Nights which I can spend with my husband, going out for dinner or watching movies together, cherishing these last few moments when it’s just the two of us, before it becomes the three of us.

I have told myself throughout my pregnancy that I will carry my baby to term.  It’s been a mantra of sorts, because I know many nurses and midwives who’ve had issues with preterm contractions and preterm births, predicaments which are certainly not helped along by their jobs.  While at work I was always very careful to hydrate myself constantly, and to sit whenever possible, and to try to leave the heavy-lifting to others during births.  But maybe so much of my mental focus was spent telling my body to keep the baby in, that now that I am finally full term, my body is having a hard time letting the baby go.  Or maybe I am just hyper-analyzing this.  First babies tend to come late, past the due date, and this is a first baby.

I am trying to not be too impatient, just because I am so eager to finally meet this little one!  I trust my body, and I trust the timing of my body and baby.  And really, my baby will come at the right time, when he is ready.  In the meantime…I can catch up on my blogging. ;-)

Posted in Homebirth, Pregnancy | Leave a comment

What happens when midwives get pregnant?

<insert Monty Python voice> And now for something completely different…

I’ve been keeping this news to myself for quite some time here.  I guess I’m finally ready to blog about it (not that anyone is currently reading this anyway, so it’s more or less like writing in my journal), but guess what??  I’m pregnant!  And not just a little bit pregnant, I am actually quite pregnant: 34 weeks today, to be precise, just three weeks away from full term.

We’re planning a homebirth with two lovely homebirth midwives in attendance  who have been caring for me since I was 10 weeks pregnant.  There will be a doula as well (one of my good friends who is also a Labor & Delivery nurse, whom I met while working as an L&D nurse back in 2003), and of course my husband, and my best friend; a small but incredibly supportive birth team.  And a birth tub, which we’re renting (and which we still need to pick up).  The list of things I need to prepare for the birth is still quite long, and a bit overwhelming, even.  At this point, we still don’t even have a name for the child yet (who is a boy, btw; even if I had wanted a surprise, I knew exactly what I was looking at during the sonogram, and could see the tiny little penis quite clearly).  We don’t have a pediatrician picked out, either.  The birth kit is in the mail but not yet arrived. And don’t even get me started on the list of baby stuff which we still need to acquire before the birth, diapers being priority number one. There is a lot to get done in the next few weeks.

From an emotional standpoint, though, I feel like I’ve been taking it all pretty well in stride.  I’ve had (thankfully) a very healthy and straightforward pregnancy so far.  I’ve felt good for the majority of the pregnancy, aside from some nausea and fatigue in the first trimester; all of my blood tests have been normal, the sonogram looked good, everything is healthy and low-risk at this point.  He’s a very active little guy, he squirms and moves nearly constantly, he likes to dance while I’m listening to music, and always kicks his happy appreciation of all of the good food I’ve been eating during the pregnancy.  Current pregnancy complaints amount to a sore back (totally expected, in the third trimester), and having to get up and pee about 3-4 times a night.  I’ve been working my usual schedule, and if all continues to go well, my intention is to work up until 38 weeks, or until I give birth, whichever comes first.

When I was a younger woman, still in midwifery school, I used to worry about my own birth.  I used to worry that I would know too much, that I wouldn’t be able to turn my brain off and surrender myself to the forces of labor when the time came, that I would be the classic example of the woman who’s trying to give birth with her brain rather than her body, and whose brain is getting in the way of the labor.  I worried that something bad would happen; there is a superstition among healthcare workers that pregnant nurses/ midwives/ doctors etc. tend to have a much higher rate of rare and frightening emergencies during their labors and births which somehow necessitate every intervention under the sun, or result in tragic and terrible outcomes.  I have heard this superstition passed around before—that bad things always happen to healthcare workers—and when I was younger I used to worry about it too.  And I have worried in the past that I will somehow by disappointed by my birth experience—that because I have so much knowledge, and such a love of birth, and so much expectation going into it, that inevitably there is no way my own birth could live up to such high standards.  The flip side of this is the fear that I am never going to be cared for as well or as completely as I care for other women; that the care I receive will fall short of my own lofty standards and expectations, and that I will never be given as much as I have given to other women during their births.

Like I said, these are old worries.  I stumbled across them while I was paging through an old journal of mine a few weeks ago, written down in 2005 while I was taking a Birthing From Within mentor training course in order to be able to teach Birthing From Within childbirth classes.  Strangely enough, these worries now seem foreign to me.  At least, they’re not the things I’ve actually been worrying about during my pregnancy.  I feel like the birth will be very difficult—the hardest thing I’ve ever done in my life—but that it’s totally do-able, and that I will absolutely get through it, however hard or long it is.  I’m not really hung up on interventions, or trying to ensure that they don’t occur.  I feel like I’ll have them if I need them, but if all goes smoothly, then hopefully it will be a straightforward, uneventful homebirth. I don’t feel like I’m dead-set on a homebirth no matter what; if there are recurrent decels, or thick meconium, any indication of severe distress, or any other pressing reason, we’ll go to a hospital.  If I need a cesarean in the end, at least I know that I will be one of the women who really, truly does need a cesarean, rather than getting pressured into it by an impatient or uncaring provider.  If I’m having an exhausting 48+ hour labor with excruciating back labor and things are going really slowly, I’m not opposed to an epidural, either, and some rest.  Thankfully my midwife has hospital admitting privileges if we need them, and there is a hospital very close to us for emergencies.  I don’t think we’ll end up in a hospital, but I’m ready to weather whatever my birth throws at me, and I’m trying to cultivate a flexible roll-with-the-punches attitude.  But I think of all the births I have attended (326 now, and counting), each unique in its own way and yet also so similar, and I think of all the women who I have been with who get to a point where they truly believe that they can’t go on, that they can’t do it, that their baby will never come, that they’ll never give birth etc. etc…and then I watch them climb that mountain and get over it and do the impossible thing they didn’t think they were capable of, and give birth—simply, normally, vaginally, uneventfully.  And honestly, it gives me tremendous faith in the process.  I’m sure I too will get to the point where I am convinced I won’t be able to do it…and then I will.  I have faith that I will, and I feel like my faith is what will get me through it (and my smart and attentive care providers will make sure that we’re not taking any unnecessary risks, should we fall off the curve of normal, and I trust them, and their judgement, implicitly).

So no, I haven’t been worrying much about the birth.  I’ve been worrying more about motherhood, about the huge and tremendous responsibility which is about to descend on me.  I’ve been worrying that I won’t be a good mother, or a good enough mother, that the task will be too much for me, that my child will hate or resent me, that I’ll somehow mess my poor child up in terrible, Freudian, unfathomable ways.  And of course I’ve been worrying over the health of my baby.  I pray that he’ll be healthy, and neurologically intact, and strong.  Every pregnant woman does, I’m certain.

But I took the time to write down a gazillion birth affirmations last night, and I’ve been saying them to myself regularly today.  Simple things, but I also believe in the power of positive thought:

I am a strong and powerful woman. I believe in myself. I trust my body.  My baby is strong and healthy. My cervix knows what to do.  I have an open heart.  I am surrounded by loving, nurturing support.  I trust my inner wisdom.  Birth will come easily to me. I have everything I need. I welcome my coming labor as the perfect one for me and my baby.  I deserve and receive all the love and support I need. I deserve a gentle, natural birth. I claim my birthright for a wonderful birth.  I will be a wonderful mother.

Posted in Homebirth, Labor and Birth, Vaginal Birth | Leave a comment

CPM bill introduced in Congress

I have already written extensively on the differences between CNMs/ CMs and CPMs, about how there is a national divide between these qualifications which may prove very hard to bridge, and about how the lack of a unified standard of midwifery in the US continues to divide and destabilize our profession.  Part of the problem is that laws vary so greatly between state to state.  In some states, Certified Professional Midwives (CPMs) are legal, in other states they are not  recognized at all and must practice illegally and under the radar, even though they have studied and and been credentialed by a national certification board (NARM, the North American Registry of Midwives). It’s rather infuriating, given that the only thing stopping them from legal recognition and practice are the state to state differences in law. I’m not really going to go through the differences between CPMs/ CNMs/ CMs (read the link above), but instead focus on the fact that some very exciting legislation has recently been introduced by Congresswoman Chellie Pingree in an attempt to gain federal recognition of CPMs (thus eliminating the state-by-state discrepancies) as well as allowing them to be medicaid providers.  The rational behind this is that once Medicaid recognizes a  specific type of clinician as a medicaid provider, all of the other insurance companies usually follow Medicaid’s lead.  You can read the full text of the the proposed legislation here: H.R. 1054. The driving force behind this legislation is the MAMA campaign, spearheaded by the Midwives Alliance of North America (MANA) and Citizens for Midwifery (CfM).

In New York State, CNMs/ CMs practice legally but CPMs do not.  I personally know of several friends who have had lovely, safe, wonderful births attended by CPMs in this state, but unfortunately these midwives did so illegally, with no back-up and no recourse if something went wrong.  Being charged with practicing medicine without a license is very serious, and especially tragic given that CPMs do have certifications, but are unable to obtain licences in various states depending on state legislation.   How wonderful it would be if CPMs were federally recognized the same way CNMs are (although the bitter politician in me wonders if the ACNM is going to welcome this legislation with open arms).  In any case, check out the MAMA campaign, and let’s keep our fingers crossed!

Posted in Homebirth, Issues, Midwifery, News, Politics | Leave a comment

NIH Consensus updates on VBACs

One of the advantages to being a midwife is being on all kinds of funky mailing lists, which means that all softs of health information, conference invitations, and sometimes even free samples often show up on my doorstep.  A few days ago, I got just such a mailing– the NIH Consensus Development Conference Statement on Vaginal Birth After Cesarean: New Insights. Granted, this is from 2010, but nevertheless represents the most current and updated NIH State-of-the-Science statement to date.

A consensus panel of 15 non-advocate representatives (i.e. not lobbyists) from different disciplines (obstetrics, gynecology, pediatrics, maternal and fetal medicine, midwifery, clinical pharmacology, medical ethics, nursing, anesthesiology, risk management etc. etc.) got together and performed a thorough literature review and listened to presentations by experts, and then drafted the consensus report, posted above.  Pretty nifty, given the amount of information they had to wade through, and the fact that not all of the research available is good research.  I really liked the fact that the statement divides all of its research up into “High Grade of Evidence”, “Moderate Grade of Evidence”, “Low Grade of Evidence” and “Insufficient Evidence”.  My only complaint is that there isn’t actually a reference list at the back of the statement, and none of the research papers they are discussing are actually cited, so it makes it much harder to find and look at the research yourself.

And what does it say?  Basically, that the VBAC rate is still plummeting, and more research is needed.  Big surprise there.  The VBAC rate has been plummeting for decades, ever since its record high in 1996 of 28.3%.  It also seemed to suggest that ACOG could play a much bigger role in encouraging the practice of VBACs again, but maybe that was just my wishful thinking.

The statement begins by systematically reviewing the evidence behind the short-term and long-term benefits and harms of trial of labor v. repeat cesarean from the perspective of both mothers and babies.   Some of the benefits of trial of labor for mothers includes a decreased risk of maternal mortality when compared to repeat cesarean (high grade of evidence).  There is also a lower risk of hysterectomy (moderate grade of evidence), lower incidence of placental complications with future pregnancies, such as placenta previa, and placenta accreta/ increta/ percreta, (moderate grade of evidence), and shorter hospital-stays, with possible decreased risks of DVT (low grade of evidence).  Among the risks of trial of labor for mothers includes incidence of uterine rupture (moderate grade evidence), which is increased if there is a classical incision, i.e. a vertical uterine scar (however, there was only low-grade evidence to support this).  It’s also interesting to note that there was insufficient evidence to support the claim that repeat cesareans help avoid future pelvic floor dysfunction.

From the babies perspective, the perinatal mortality rate and neonatal mortality rate were observed to be lower in babies receiving repeat cesareans as opposed to trial of labor (moderate grade of evidence), and slightly higher rates of hypoxic eschemic encephalopathy in babies receiving a trial of labor (low grade of evidence).

To my way of thinking, though, the more important part of this statement is the fact that it also looked into many of the non-medical factors that are influencing the declining VBAC rate, such as professional association practice guidelines (ACOG’s 1999 Practice Guideline on VBAC being a big one), hospital and health-insurance policies, and professional liability concerns among physicians and hospitals.  I have heard my OB colleagues joke among themselves that the only bad cesarean is the one that isn’t done.  The general outlook that I have observed seems to be that doing a cesarean is always the right way to go from a medical-legal perspective; cesareans are perceived as being safer, by doctors and patients, no matter what the situation, and if in doubt, it’s better to err on the side of doing a cesarean than not.  This attitude can be found all over the place.  To quote a comment made by an obstetrician on KevinMD.com: “You never get sued for doing a cesarean section, you get sued for not doing one. So given the scenario with a questionable fetal heart rate tracing where any “expert witness” can find fault with, (even if there is none) I would rather perform a cesarean section than not. It comes down to a matter of staying in practice and making a living.”

The last Practice Guideline that ACOG has issued on the subject came out in 1999, and reversed its prior encouragement of VBACs, instead saying that women should be “offered” (rather than “encouraged” to have) a trial of labor if there are no contraindications, but basically asserting that it’s a personal decision, and can be decided on between doctor and patient on a case-by-case basis.  The 1999 Practice Guideline also stated that trials of labor should only be done in hospitals ready to respond to emergencies with on-call physicians always available to perform an emergency cesarean, as well as 24-hour on-call anesthesiology coverage (a standard which many rural and smaller hospitals find very difficult to comply with).   It’s important to note that this recommendation was rated as a Level C in the ACOG Guideline (i.e. based on consensus expert opinion, with no hard evidence to support it).  Nevertheless, many hospitals and providers have cited the lack of these emergency provisions as the reason that they no longer offer women trials of labor.

In it’s conclusion, the NIH consensus report directly addresses this issue:

Given the low level of evidence for the requirement of “immediately available” surgical and anesthesia personnel in current guidelines, we recommend that the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and the American Society of Anesthesiologists reassess this requirement with specific reference to other obstetric complications of comparable risk, risk stratification, and in light of limited physician and nursing resources.

We now know so much more about the causes of uterine rupture and the safety of VBACs than we did 20 years ago when the practice was first encouraged.  We know that the use of prostoglandin induction agents such as cytotec and cervadil were a chief cause of uterine rupture, and that women with low-transverse uterine incisions actually have a pretty low rate of uterine rupture.  With this in mind, it’s probably time for ACOG to finally issue a new Practice Guideline on VBACs.

A last comment about the NIH report: they left a laundry list of critical gaps missing from the research, highlighting the places where more information is desperately needed, which was nice to see.  They also issued a few choice words about the “cesearean as best defense” mentality:

We are concerned that medical-legal considerations add to, and in many instances exacerbate, these barriers to trial of labor.  Policymakers, providers, and other stakeholders must collaborate in developing and implementing appropriate strategies to mitigate the chilling effect the medical-legal environment has on access to care.

I couldn’t agree more!  Thank you, NIH, for a well-written and informative report.  Maybe this will help swing the momentum back in favor of VBACs again!

 

Posted in Cesarean Birth, Complications, Hospitals, Labor and Birth, Research, Vaginal Birth, VBAC | Leave a comment

Vaginal twins at 25 weeks

So one of the advantages of working as a midwife in a hospital is that I get to participate in many births that I wouldn’t have the opportunity to experience in private practice.  If I were working as a private practice midwife, and as a homebirth midwife in particular, there is no way I would be able to assist at a delivery of preterm twins.  But, in a hospital such as mine, especially since there are no residents, we midwives often find ourselves helping and working with many of the high-risk women.  Today was a case in point.  This woman had been admitted early last week with preterm premature rupture of membranes (PPROM) at only 24 weeks gestation, which is never good news in singleton pregnancies, and even more worrisome in twin gestations because the babies are even smaller since they’re sharing a womb.  She was admitted and given steroids to help develop the babies lungs, and put on bed-rest in an attempt to slow down the labor; we also gave her prophylactic antibiotics since PPROM is often caused by infection, and with ruptured membranes, infection is always a risk.  Luckily we were able to get all of the steroid doses on board before the delivery of the babies, and she stayed on the antepartum unit for nearly a week before the labor continued to progress, going from 24 to 25 weeks gestation in the process–and every day was a blessing in a case like this, since every day helps.

Even so, 25 weeks is extremely premature, right on the cusp of viability.  She was moved to L&D this morning because she had begun to contract regularly again, and was feeling increased pressure.  We were able to hold her off for most of the day, but one of the doctors did a sterile speculum exam towards evening in order to visually assess the cervix (vaginal exams are avoided as much as possible when a woman has broken her water, since they tend to increase the risk of infection), and all the doctor saw was a head of hair, without any cervix covering it at all.  A vaginal exam afterwards quickly confirmed what she had suspected: the patient was nearly fully dilated, and the first twin had moved far down into the pelvis, to nearly +1 station.  Initially we thought she might need a cesarean, but a sonogram quickly confirmed the first twin was vertex (obviously…this was the twin that was presenting) and that the second twin was very nearly vertex (more transverse, but with the head still sloping downward).  After consulting with the MFM and attending pediatricians, the decision was made to attempt a vaginal delivery, since one of the risks of extreme prematurity is cerebral hemorrhage in the fetus, and pushing a tiny, head-first twin back up through the bony pelvis in order to deliver through the abdomen was sure to cause more damage, rather than less.  Nevertheless, she was taken to the OR for the delivery just in case a cesarean was needed after all.

All hands were on deck, and the OR was packed.  The attending OB physician was there, the back-up attending was also there, and I was there. We were the delivery team.  Two attending pediatricians, 3 pediatrician residents, and 2 neonatal nurses were also there, divided into two groups–one for each tiny twin.  We had two warmers ready for the twins, two isolettes, two laryngoscopes, two sets of everything.  The anesthesiologist was present and on standby in case we needed to put the patient under general anesthesia for an emergency cesarean.  There were also 3 L&D nurses on hand; one scrubbed and ready to assist in a stat cesarean, and the other two as runners/ circulating nurses.  And a medical student, who was observing (with the patient’s permission)–and holding her hand, and feeding her ice chips.

She was nervous, naturally.  This was her first pregnancy, she’d never pushed before, and she still wasn’t feeling the contractions very strongly (one of the hallmarks of preterm contractions is that they tend to be painless).  We set the sonogram machine next to the patient, and the back-up attending used it throughout the birth to help assess the position of the second twin (twin B), as well as the fetal hearts of both twins throughout the pushing.  We gave her reassurance, helped hold her legs, got her into a good position, and then asked her to push.  Amazingly (well, not really, given how small these babies are, and how low in the pelvis the first twin already was), it took only a few strong pushes before the tiny little head was starting to crown in the vagina.  Before we knew it, the first tiny twin was out, a red little girl weighing only 1 lb 6 oz.  I helped deliver the head and quickly clamped and cut the cord; the attending OB handed the tiny baby to the waiting peds team, and they instantly got to work, intubating and ventilating her tiny little lungs.  She never cried, but she was nice and pink, and waving her little arms and legs around.  Within minutes she was intubated and stabilized, and the team quickly moved her to the NICU.  Meanwhile, we were concentrating on twin B.

The back-up physician was applying steady fundal pressure on the uterus, helping to hold twin B in a vertex position and guide her into the pelvis.  After a few more contractions, the uterus began to close around twin B and push her down into the pelvis.  Once she was engaged, the OB attending broke the second amniotic sac, and we asked the mom to begin to push again, which she did with renewed energy (having gotten a brief rest after the delivery of twin A).  About 10 minutes later, twin B was also crowning, and again, we quickly delivered the baby, clamped and cut the cord, and handed the twin to the second peds team.  She as another tiny little girl, this time 1 lb 8 oz, and again, doing as well as could possibly be hoped for at only 25 weeks gestation.  Once she as stable, she too was moved to the NICU, and the OR began to clear out a bit.

It’s quite an amazing sight, to see two umbilical cords presenting.  We waited for awhile, and slowly the cords began to lengthen as the placenta separated from the uterus.  About 15 minutes after the delivery of Twin B the placenta came out–much larger than a singleton placenta, with two cords and two separate amniotic sacs (di-chorionic/ di-amniotic).  Once the placenta was out, we all breathed a sigh of relief.  A quick exam showed that the woman was intact (not surprising, given how tiny the babies were).  We cleaned her up, took out the foley catheter we had put in just in case she needed a cesarean, and transferred her to the recovery room, where her family was waiting. And there you have it: a remarkably straightforward vaginal twin delivery at 25 weeks gestation.  Not exactly something your average midwife gets to see everyday, but certainly something I felt very lucky to have been able to experience.

Posted in Birth Stories, Complications, Hospitals, Labor and Birth, Vaginal Birth | Leave a comment