The Keeper

keeper
We’ve been talking so much about menstruation lately that it seems only natural that the subject of alternative menstrual gear would come up at some point. In fact, just last week we were talking about it after class one day, and I ended up bringing my Keeper to school with me to show to a few curious classmates. Frankly, it’s high time that this website had a position statement on alternative menstrual gear. This is something I believe very strongly in, and something I have personally been using for several years now, and it seems just plain Wrong that I haven’t been talking it up something fierce on my own website already. So, enough is enough. Time to spread the good word.

The word goes something like this: About five years ago, I was broke (notice how much has changed in the intervening five years!). I had recently befriended a woman who lived in my neighborhood, and one evening, while hanging out at her house, I noticed that she had a bunch of terry cloth pads laid out next to her sewing machine, made from a cut-up bath towel. When I asked her what they were for, she introduced me to the concept of alternative, reuseable menstrual gear. I was, to put it mildly, a bit flabbergasted. Keep in mind, I was a good girl from the midwest, who’d only been living in New York City for two years at that point, and still hadn’t fully lost my shy, midwestern ways. The message that our society sadly pounds into the skulls of young women (myself included) is that your period is dirty, something that needs to be kept secret and “sanitary”, and most definitely hidden from others. As girls, we’re taught that menstruation is an unfortunate part of growing up, a curse, or at the very least, a major, monthly pain in the ass—something that needs to be tolerated and dealt with, but rarely something that should be celebrated and enjoyed. As part of our induction into womanhood, we’re inundated with ads from the feminine “hygiene” industry, promoting the benefits of this product over that, and encouring the idea that the selection of a feminine hygiene brand is an important rite of passage. All of this just compounds the sense of shame and embarrassment that so many of us feel about our bodies—magazines are full of ways for us to “fix” our bodies, lose weight and attract the man of our dreams by wearing the right clothes and smelling the right way. Commercials for pads and tampons rave about how fresh, clean and discrete their products are. Douches urge us to “cleanse” our (naturally dirty?) vaginas so that they’re strawberry-scented or flower-fresh (and cause untold infections in the process through drastic vaginal flora disruption).

The feminine hygiene industry is a billion dollar industry that feeds off of women’s insecurities and doubts, and has us all suckered into the idea that spending $200 on menstrual products a year is just an unavoidable part of being a woman. Let me put it this way: do you think men would spend $200 a year on hygiene products if they too had an unavoidable monthly biological process that was part of their healthy life-cycle? I’m guessing not. If men had menstrual cycles, I bet health insurance companies would have started covering the expense of their supplies long ago, since, after all, these products would be essential to the health of the insured, same way insurance companies will pay for prenatal vitamins, or the needles and glucometers of diabetics. Why should women be expected to pay out-of-pocket for something that’s part of their yearly health and wellness? (This is somewhat similar to the “logic” used when health insurance companies will pay for viagra, but refuse to cover birth control…but that’s a rant I’ll save for another day). Women have been using cloth for centuries. It’s only very recently that we’ve been expected to pay every month for the pleasure of bleeding onto pearly white, cotton pads.

One woman, in her lifetime, will go through close to 11,000 pads or tampons. That’s a huge amount of uneeded waste going straight to the landfill. The women on this earth account for 51% of the population. If all of us use 11,000 pads in our lifetimes…that’s gotta be a landfill the size of Australia! It’s worth switching to re-useable products for that reason alone, but wait, there’s more: disposable pads suck! Not only do they take up way too much space, and get tossed out after only a few hours of use, but the packaging that comes with the products (the boxes and applicators) are also nothing but landfill fodder, and often end up washing up on beaches. While the FDA assures us that tampon companies no longer use chlorine-bleaching processes to get those pure, snow-white results they’re looking for, this was a practice that was used for decades before the FDA recently outlawed it, and untold amounts of toxic dioxins have been released into our environment because of it, disrupting ecosystems and bioaccumulating in lakes and rivers. (The FDA was also very quick to dismiss the idea that the dioxins in tampons can cause TSS or possibly cancer, but even without the dioxins, tampons are still perfectly capable of causing TSS on their own, just by being such a lovely, squidgy vector for bacteria and infetion). Sadly, dioxin is a very persistent chemical, and even though companies now use chlorine-free bleaching processes, the damage has already been done. Our children and grandchildren will be drinking and eating trace amounts of dioxin in their water and food for decades to come, thanks to the toxic feminine hygiene industry. And I ask you this: why is it necessary that the cotton and rayon of pads and tampons be bleached in the first place? They’re not sterile products that are used for surgery or wounds; they don’t have to be bleached.

Anyway, to make a long story short, my initial reaction to my friend’s cotton pads was “eeewwww!!”, however, it didn’t take long for her arguments to make sense to me: 1) I was broke, and the idea of saving $200 a year not spending that money on pads was very appealing, and 2) I have always been trying to find ways to make my environmental footprint on this earth a little bit lighter, and using cloth pads seemed like a really simple thing to change, which actually has a very large cumulative impact. So I purchased a starter kit of reuseable cloth pads to take care of all my monthly needs and voila!, I was hooked. I’ll let others extol the virtues of free-bleeding, but for my own part, there was something deliciously empowering about taking this aspect of my life out of commercial, profit-driven hands, and into my own capable, human hands. There was also something immensely satisfying about blowing raspberries at the TV screen whenever an ad for tampons came on, and feeling smug and pleased with the knowledge that while other women spent money on pads every month, I didn’t! Course, this method required a certain non-squeamishness when it came to blood, and a willingness to wear heavy cloth pads in my underwear once a month (which did, I must admit, feel like I had a phone book between my legs every now and then), and of course I had to soak them and launder them appropriately. For about two years, this routine suited me just fine (and cloth pads are great, and continue to work well for millions of women around the world)…but then…THEN…I discovered the joys of the Keeper.

Believe me, once I was finally sold on the beauty and sustainability of cloth pads, I was a true-blue, born-again convert, however, I have found that I prefer the Keeper to cloth pads, which means that in my book, it’s really very VERY good. This little cup is a latex product that fits inside of your vagina and functions a lot like an OB tampon, collecting your menstrual flow without drying out your vaginal walls. It requires insertion with your fingers, and periodic emptying (your collected flow can be conveniently emptied into the toilet, then the Keeper can be wiped off and reinserted); I must admit, it does take a little bit of effort to learn how to get it in and out, but once you master it, this is by far the easiest form of menstrual protection I have ever used, AND it’s ecologically friendly, sustainable, reuseable, and relatively cheap, given that you only have to buy one, and then you’re set for the next 10 years. Another beauty of using a menstrual cup is the fact that you don’t have to change your cup nearly as often as you have to change a tampon. On light days, towards the end of my bleeding cycle, I can happily put my Keeper in during my morning shower, and leave it in all day, and forget that it’s even there. And then, at the end of your cycle, all you have to do is wash it out with antibacterial soap, let it soak overnight in a bowl of water mixed with a tablespoon of hydrogen peroxide, white vinegar or tea tree oil, and that’s it. So, for those of you who like functionality of tampons (and the lack of phone-book-between-your-legs), but would also like to stop feeding the fat purse of the toxic feminine hygiene industry, and do our planet a major favor, a menstrual cup is definitely the way to go. The Mooncup and Divacup are also every bit as fantastic as the Keeper, they’re just made out of silicone instead of latex, so for those of you with latex allergies, rest assured, there are menstrual cups out there for you, too!

That’s pretty much the end of my schpiel. I know that what works for some women certainly won’t work for all women, but I urge you to think about your menstrual choices. Once you start using alternative methods, you begin to wonder why you ever needed a 7th-grade introduction to feminine hygiene products in the first place. I started using alternative methods about five years ago, and I haven’t once looked back.

For further reading:

The Wise Wound by Shuttle, Redgrove & Drabble.

The Woman in the Body by Emily Martin.

This entry was posted in Feminism, Menstruation, New Products, The Soapbox, Women's Health. Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

8 Comments

  1. TinaH
    Posted February 10, 2006 at 7:17 am | Permalink

    I started getting a lot fewer cramps when I started using my flannel pads…

  2. Posted February 10, 2006 at 8:40 pm | Permalink

    Thanks for introducing the Keeper, I didn’t know about it before!! I’ll spread the word among my friends, too. It’s fascinating and makes so much sense. And it seems easy. I’m definitely going to look into it and probably order one… yay!

  3. The Student
    Posted February 12, 2006 at 8:37 pm | Permalink

    Kyra: Oh, excellent! I hope it works for you as well as it has worked for me. Please let me know what you think of it! Give it at least a month or two to get the hang of it before you make up your mind. Congrats on being open to such an awesome change in your life, and good luck!

  4. Posted February 14, 2006 at 2:08 pm | Permalink

    Thank you for sharing this information. I have read about disposable diaper for children and I thought it was a pretty neat idea, I think I might go ahead and buy a Keeper…I never felt comfortable wearing a tampon for more than a couple of hours, but with a Keeper I think that I wouldn’t have that problem.

    Thanks again,
    Bebu

  5. Posted February 15, 2006 at 9:29 pm | Permalink

    Hooray for talking up The Keeper. I’ve been using it since 1994, I think, and I love it!!

  6. The Student
    Posted February 16, 2006 at 7:00 am | Permalink

    Tinah: I seem to recall Inga Muscio talking about a similar phenomenon in her book Cunt (which is a very radical but very fun book, once you get into it). Once she switched from tampons to cloth products, her periods got much lighter, and her cramps all but disappeared. She blamed it on the toxic chemical bi-products that exist in tampons, and felt that the tampon/feminine hygiene industry was self-perpetuating: once you started using those products, which made you crampy and your flow heavier, you were bound to use MORE of those products because of the increased flow, as well as a ton of advil and other NSAIDs, which then made you even more reliant on medications during your period. She felt that the best way to break the cycle was to stop using commercial products for your period, period. Which you’ve apparently discovered, too.

    Bebu: good luck to you too! Again, lemme know how it goes, if you do end up making the switch. I am most curious.

    Becca: Hi!

  7. The Student
    Posted February 16, 2006 at 7:03 am | Permalink

    One addendum to the Keeper: I didn’t mention this in the main post, but for those of you thinking of switching to a menstrual cup, you might want to buy a few cloth pads as well to use at night. The Keeper is great, and you can leave it in for a long time, but I have found that it’s really nice to give your vagina a break for a little while, and not wear the Keeper 24 hours a day, for 3-5 days. The nice folks who make the Keeper recommend the same thing (I think because of concerns about retrograde flow, although don’t quote me on that). Anyway, my usual routine is to use cloth pads at night, and let my vagina breathe a bit, and then use the keeper all day/evening, until I go to bed.

  8. Posted July 11, 2013 at 11:14 pm | Permalink

    WOW just what I was searching for. Came here by searching for lady health

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>